Ronald McHaffie stated he had huge plans to construct a ski resort close to Hope, 150 km east of Vancouver, forward of the 2010 Olympics.

He lower an unlikely determine, with a Grizzly Adams beard and no historical past of resort growth.

But the Bigfoot Ski Resort’s web site was stuffed with guarantees — world-class snowboarding, a golf course, a fishing lodge and an “vintage prepare” carrying visitors across the facility. The web site, which now exists in archived type, purported to point out endorsements from all three ranges of presidency, and a spread of permits.

McHaffie gathered $642,000 from dozens of traders, telling them development was simply “across the nook,” in response to a 2014 B.C. Securities Fee ruling.

However the provincial authorities had already rejected the undertaking. The fee stated McHaffie’s claims “had been all lies,” and he put the traders’ cash in his personal account, blowing it on “private bills,” together with groceries and fuel.

When the CBC tracked him down in 2013, he was dwelling in a dilapidated cellular house within the B.C. Inside city of Princeton.

The fee fined McHaffie and ordered him to pay again the cash within the 2014 ruling, however he died final yr, leaving $2.64 million in debt to the fee, representing a $2 million penalty and the disgorgement of the traders’ cash.

His case, and the path of annoyed traders it left behind, is much from distinctive. McHaffie is amongst greater than 400 people and firms that the B.C. Securities Fee says owe about $430 million in unpaid administrative penalties and disgorgement orders.

The unpaid quantity far overshadows the $12.7 million the fee says it has collected within the final six fiscal years, reflecting challenges that embody authorized motion, absconding offenders, and resistance to the company’s authority.

Dan Valliquette of Parksville, B.C., calls the fee a “very toothless entity.”

He misplaced about $47,000 to McHaffie, an ordeal that also stings greater than a decade later.

“I at all times thought that somebody couldn’t lie that a lot and take your cash as a result of it could be unlawful,” stated Valliquette, an electrician and operations supervisor for an power agency.

He stated it was a “main mistake” to belief not solely McHaffie, however the authorized system to guard him.

“On the finish (the fee) did communicate to me and say that ‘yeah he has been fined this quantity,’ however in the identical breath they principally stated that there’s little or no likelihood that they’ll receives a commission out,” Valiquette stated.

“I believe most individuals suppose that this exercise could be legal and are extra relaxed about investing as a result of they suppose that the police or that the system will defend them.”


McHaffie’s debt died with him, however a few of these sanctioned are in jail, some are corporations which have been dissolved, others are preventing penalties in courtroom and plenty of extra merely haven’t any means to pay.

Greater than 1 / 4 of the cash owed to the B.C. Securities Fee, about $130 million, is unlikely to ever be recovered, it says.

Now, one other potential hurdle looms for the fee and different regulators, with the Supreme Courtroom of Canada set to rule whether or not chapter wipes out money owed from administrative penalties. If the appellants, a B.C. couple who owe the fee about $19 million, succeed, it might have dire penalties for the gathering of different unpaid quantities.

Amendments to British Columbia’s Securities Act in 2020 gave the fee new assortment powers, comparable to the power to disclaim drivers’ licenses or car insurance coverage to these with unpaid fines.

“The BCSC has additionally been vigorously pursuing sanctioned people for unpaid penalties, together with utilizing the instruments within the 2020 Securities Act amendments,” the fee instructed the provincial authorities in a service plan doc in February 2023.

“Whereas our use of the brand new instruments has been efficient in encouraging some funds, our efforts are being met with a number of authorized challenges within the courts which ends up in delays and the diversion of litigation assets from different enforcement efforts.”

Doug Muir, the fee’s director of enforcement, stated in an interview that $179 million owed to the fee is tied to simply 4 circumstances.

One entails Michael Lathigee and Earle Pasquill, whose Freedom Funding Membership group defrauded lots of of traders out of hundreds of thousands of {dollars}, resulting in the pair being sanctioned $51.7 million in 2014.

The fee’s pursuit of the lads over the previous decade has resulted in some small victories. Nevertheless it additionally highlights the issue tackling recalcitrant targets and their methods to keep away from paying.

Lathigee, who couldn’t be reached for remark, moved to Las Vegas the place his spouse fought the B.C. regulator’s enforcement efforts in a Nevada courtroom.

He paid the fee US$350,000 and entered a settlement settlement in April 2023 after the Nevada Supreme Courtroom deemed the fee’s cost orders enforceable within the U.S. However the quantity is a fraction of the $15 million in penalties and $21.7 million in disgorgement ordered by the B.C. regulator.

“We’ll proceed to proceed in opposition to Mr. Lathigee till we will’t any additional and we are likely to take it so long as we will,” Muir stated. “Whether or not we find yourself getting full cost or not, I can’t say, however we’re actually not going to let up from making an attempt.”

Pasquill in the meantime transferred property to his spouse Vicki Pasquill, and the fee and the couple proceed to battle it out in courtroom.

In December final yr, the B.C. Supreme Courtroom refused to dismiss the fee’s motion in opposition to the Pasquills and an organization by which Vicki Pasquill owns Vancouver actual property.

The ruling described how fraudsters “will construction their affairs prematurely of precarious transactions, promotions, and different actions, typically transferring property to relations or different third events, in an effort to defend themselves from future judgments and sanctions.”

It stated Michael Lathigee and Earle Pasquill’s failure to pay their sanctions had pressured the regulator to pursue property held by their wives, in a “secondary collections motion that may be rendered pointless if the fee is ready to gather from any of the first targets.”

The courtroom acknowledged the 2020 amendments to the Securities Act, describing a “outstanding” and distinctive provision to permit forfeiture orders in opposition to property that had been transferred under market worth to relations “at any time,” together with earlier than a violation.

Such restructuring efforts now face stiffer scrutiny beneath the brand new guidelines.

However one other technique within the tremendous evader’s playbook stays in play — declaring chapter.


Chapter “stays a favoured instrument in … efforts to flee the results of misconduct beneath the Securities Act,” the B.C. Securities Fee says in courtroom paperwork.

The fee says 44 sanctioned people owing greater than $83 million have declared chapter. The regulator has solely been in a position to gather about $300,000 from them.

The choice from the Supreme Courtroom of Canada involving the B.C. couple might have main implications for whether or not any of the remainder is ever collected. The case was heard in December and a ruling is anticipated later this yr.

Thalbinder Singh Poonian and Shailu Poonian declare they’ll be in debt to the fee “possible for all times,” owing about $19 million after being discovered to have engaged in market manipulation of an organization’s inventory in 2015. The fee dominated the couple boosted the value of OSE Corp. on the Toronto Inventory Alternate by buying and selling amongst themselves, kin, buddies and acquaintances, then bought the shares on the inflated costs to unsuspecting consumers.

The Poonians and the B.C. Securities Fee agree that the courtroom’s discovering will have an effect on securities regulators throughout Canada.

The fee says chapter shouldn’t wipe the slate clear for individuals whose debt arises from “intentional wrongdoing or different morally blameworthy conduct,” and the chapter system can’t be used “to keep away from the results of their conduct.”

“The query of whether or not these sanctions proceed to be enforceable after discharge from chapter … is a matter of public significance not just for the events to this enchantment, however for securities regulators throughout the nation and for all market contributors,” the fee says in submissions to Canada’s highest courtroom.

Success in that case “could be a big authorized victory, however doesn’t instantly get us cash to repay their sanctions,” Muir stated.

The fee has been battling the Poonians in courtroom for years, and would nonetheless must proceed assortment efforts in opposition to the couple, he stated.

Cristie Ford, a legislation professor on the College of British Columbia, stated securities frauds and schemes typically finish with no cash left to gather. However bringing enforcement motion remains to be helpful even when money owed go unpaid, or a case isn’t referred for legal prosecution.

“You deliver the enforcement motion anyway as a result of it additionally permits you to do issues like impose a ban on the particular person being a director (or) officer of a public firm going ahead, it permits you to warn the market about explicit people or concerning the firm,” she stated.

Ford stated because the amendments to the Securities Act in 2020, the B.C. Securities Fee has energy past its provincial counterparts, and though it will not be best to have hundreds of thousands excellent in penalties, “it’s higher than the choice, which isn’t to attempt to deliver these actions within the first place.”

Jean-Paul Bureaud, government director of the Canadian Basis for Development of Investor Rights, stated funding fraud has been rising at a degree that “could also be outstripping the power of regulators to maintain up.

He stated technological developments have created a “little bit of an arms race” between fraudsters and regulators, which means that investor schooling to forestall fraud is extra necessary than ever.

Whereas regulators have “moved the needle” over the previous few years of their pursuit of dangerous actors, he stated amassing cash owed stays “a problem and sadly there’s no simple answer.”

“We’d wish to see the gathering charges a lot larger,” he stated. “It’s a critical difficulty.”

Vancouver Island home painter Andy Schofield is aware of all of it too effectively.

He invested about $200,000 within the Bigfoot resort after being launched to McHaffie by a co-worker. Then McHaffie disappeared “off the face of the Earth.”

“He might need even believed in what he was doing and that’s the impression I had,” Schofield stated. “He actually believed he might make it.”

Schofield stated he didn’t know McHaffie had died, and he appears to be like again on the misfortune of assembly him by the lens of his Christian religion.

“I pray just a little tougher than I did again in these days earlier than I make daring strikes,” he stated. “I can forgive Mr. McHaffie, however the Lord’s the one who must forgive him, so hopefully he discovered God earlier than he handed. I might even see him once more in heaven and we will shake arms and have fun about this entire factor. Who is aware of?”

For fellow Bigfoot investor Valliquette, forgiveness isn’t one thing he’s prepared to increase to McHaffie.

“He was a swindler,” Valliquette stated. “I believe there’s a little bit of a false sense of safety inside Canada … till you get burned you don’t actually notice how weak the system is.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first revealed Mar. 5, 2024.


Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *